Submitted to the WSJ ():
Submitted to Smerconish.com (November 14, 2026):
Context: our traffic controller system had a problem when software was being updated, so they stopped airplanes taking off, but not those landing. Smerconish had Ben Sliney as a guest today. Sliney ordered the planes out of the sky on 9/11. Smerconish asked Sliney what was different yesterday that caused them not to tell planes to land immediately. Sliney gave a vague answer. I contacted Smerconish as follows:
1) On 9/11, terrorists on the planes were hijacking them. It was important to land planes, especially those which had just taken off, before terrorists could take them over.
2) Yesterday, the problem was probably greatest in the vicinity of airports. Directing more airplanes to the airports could have made things worse.
3) By the time long flights were ready to land on schedule, the problem may have been fixed.
Submitted to the WSJ (November 13, 2026):
Joseph
Sternberg’s excellent 11/13 article cites the common figure of $40 trillion in
US debt. But, if we want Social Security and Medicare Part A benefits to
continue “as is” indefinitely, we’re $103 trillion in the hole according to the
2026 OASDI (Table VI.F1) and Medicare (Table V.G1) trustees’
reports. That’s $933,000 for each USA taxpayer. Those numbers
double if we include projected Medicare Part B costs in excess of projected
Part B premiums (Table V.G3).
Secondly, Mr. Sternberg wrote “If a wealth
tax can’t pass in California, it is doubtful that the idea can win national
support.” But it can be legislated nationally without a vote and, as Mr.
Sternberg noted, it was defeated in CA for fear that billionaires would leave
the state. With a national wealth tax, there may be less fear of
departure.
The Concord Coalition is holding a Debt
Summit in Washington, from March 2-4, 2027. I hope to see many WSJ
readers and reporters there.
Thanks for your great work!
Submitted to the KC Star (November 13, 2026):
A more fundamental issue is that when healthcare
is nationalized, politicians are reluctant to raise taxes to maintain services. Many studies demonstrate that UK and Canadian
nationalized healthcare suffers from:
- Greater doctor shortages
than in the USA.
- Longer delays for
non-emergency surgery and diagnostic imaging.
- Fewer locations for
state-of-the-art equipment
- Fewer private rooms in
hospitals and nursing homes.
- Less care for extreme
needs. (Consider the Charlie Gard
case.)
- Less end-of-life care due
to cost/benefit analysis.
- Slower approval of new
pharmaceuticals.
- Less incentive to
develop new pharmaceuticals.
Kaiser
Family Foundation research shows insurers pay 43% more than Medicare for
doctors and 99% more for hospitals. How
will our health system work if we remove the higher payments of insurers?
More broadly, separation of powers was key to the USA’s success. Concentrated power has many disadvantages. For example, pushing more-and-more decisions to the Federal level makes Federal elections more complex and important, fueling divisiveness in our country.
Submitted to the WSJ (October 29, 2026):
Submitted to the WSJ (October 27, 2026):
Dan J. Sullivan acknowledges voting for at
least the 3 most recent Democratic presidential candidates and for Mary Peltola
for Congress in 2022 and 2024 and using a campaign consultant who serves
Democrats. Yet he changed his registration
from Independent to Republican when, just before the window closed, he registered
to run for Senator against Ms. Peltola and the incumbent Senator Dan S.
Sullivan. He had never previously run
for political office and has since changed his registration to “undeclared”. In addition to this dirty similar-name campaign
trick, there is documentation that Democratic funders paid for mailers encouraging
Republicans to vote for the fourth candidate, Republican Gerald Heikes, without
his knowledge.
In a traditional election, siphoning votes from
a major party candidate could easily turn the election. Fortunately, Alaska has ranked-choice voting. So, if voters pick Dan S. Sullivan higher
than Mary Peltola (albeit behind Dan J. Sullivan or Heikes), such chicanery will
have no impact. Hurrah for ranked-choice
voting!
Nonetheless, President Trump recently called
ranked-choice voting a “scam” and urged Alaskans to vote for Prop. 2 to end it. No matter how hard they fight each other on
other issues, the major parties work together to suppress democracy. Examples
include, but are not limited to, opposing ranked-choice voting; gerrymandering
to create safe districts for each other; and passing “sore loser” laws.
Submitted to the WSJ (October 20, 2026):
Gerard
Baker’s great piece (“America Abandons Ideals at Its Peril”) demonstrates but
doesn’t spotlight a great contribution of immigrants. Many experienced less economic and religious
freedom and less economic opportunity than we enjoy. They not only appreciate, as Mr. Baker notes,
these freedoms, they also understand how vulnerable our freedoms are. We should heed their warnings to be vigilant to
protect our rights. Sadly, our native-born
mostly disregard such warnings, too busy to be concerned and presuming “that
could never happen here”. Mr. Baker
mentions our abandonment of Ukraine and hints at potential abandonment of
Taiwan. On the same page, Elisha Wiesel exposes
ex-President Obama’s lack of support of Israel, which both the extreme left and
extreme right are happy to abandon.
Patrick Henry wisely said “United we stand, divided we fall”. Sadly, our political parties and many citizens
undermine us by dividing us from one another and from our allies.
To be Submitted to the WSJ (~August 27, 2026): I thought it best to keep my 8/17 letter silent about the value of diversity, to avoid mixing two topics. Relatively to diversity:
The Value of Diversity
A college professor pointed out that English refers to continuous functions (smooth curves) and discontinuous functions (bar graphs), whereas the Russian language has a term for what we call “discontinuous”, then a prefix is added to describe continuous functions. That was a revelation!
Western scientists' language imparts a bias that continuous functions are the natural state of the world, whereas the Russian language instills the opposite bias. My reaction was that I’d love to have Russian and Western mathematicians co-operate on space programs and nuclear power.
True diversity is based on differences in how we think, which can be influenced by gender, age, affluence, familyl status, job, education, experience, physical or mental handicaps, religion, ethnicity/culture, etc. Differences by race should be subsumed into ethnicity but there are differences by race because of human frailty.
Admitting a minority-race student who attended high-quality schools and whose parents were partners in a law firm does not necessarily add diversity. I attended an inner-city high school, by choice, and was rewarded with a rich environment of immigrants from around the world. I then looked forward to attending a university with a significant population of foreign students, only to discover that they all seemed to have attended British or American schools abroad; they added little diversity.
Submitted to the WSJ (August 17, 2026):
The New
College Race Preferences (WSJ editorial board, 10Aug26)
Although I strongly agree that DEI went off the rails, the WSJ, DOJ, and Students for Fair Admission press for admissions to be strongly correlated to test scores or other measurable metrics, which would permit a simple spreadsheet to select college classes. I believe professionals, executives, etc. should be selected based on their judgement; expected and relied upon to use that judgement properly; and evaluated based on their results.
An appropriate goal for a university is to admit those who are most likely to leverage that institution’s education effectively. Regardless of race, applicants who have done well despite difficult circumstances are more likely to overcome future obstacles and succeed. Those who have stronger motivations and character are also more likely to succeed. Such characteristics are not measurable. Regardless of race, students who had to overcome constant relocations; food and shelter uncertainty; having to work or care for younger children to support their families; being trapped in under-performing schools; or English as a second language; will, as a group, have lower test scores despite equal talent and perhaps greater motivation.
I look forward to the day when those challenges are much less common than today and equally common for all races. Until that day, I would expect racial disparities among incoming students’ test scores.
Submitted to the WSJ (August 16, 2026):
“Mangione
Admits to Killing CEO”
Providing
such publicity (front-page, top-line headline and even more unjustifiable
photo!) to someone who committed a heinous act stimulates copycats. Your
headline did not need to include his name. If you thought it was your
duty to report his name, it should have been buried on page A4. Instead,
it was mentioned 7 times in the banner article and 21 times in the
article. To me, that is outrageously irresponsible journalism.
Since Columbine, there have been 400 shootings in K-12 schools in the
USA. How many could have been avoided if the media did not provide so
much publicity to the shooters?
Submitted to the WSJ (June 6, 2026):
As
a teen-ager, I became comfortable approaching a girl I didn’t know to ask her
for a date. If she turned me down, I just reminded myself that she
doesn’t know me so her refusal couldn’t hurt my ego. Using the same
philosophy, I often start conversations with strangers. What’s the
downside? The upside is that we can learn from each other. I carry
Charitable Gift Cards to give to people (“I’ve donated $x to charity; that $x
is sitting out there waiting for you to pick which charity gets the money”);
that sparks or rewards nice conversations. But it is harder today because
more people have ear buds that discourage communication.
Published by the KC Star (April 5, 2026)
As an upper middle class Caucasian child, I loved my wonderful social education getting to know the diverse students at my inner-city high school. I agree with Mike Brannen (“When I look at my Kansas City high school graduates, I see the future”, 30Mar26) that it is good that public high schools bring together “large numbers of teens from different backgrounds, nationalities, competencies, and social classes” (even though many children don’t take advantage of that opportunity). Alas, the social education is not complemented with strong academic education. My high school lost accreditation. I later taught in inner-city Los Angeles, where I observed the failure of our public school system. Mr. Bannen acknowledges that “our high schools lag behind other countries”, “our test scores are low”, and “perhaps” our high schools have become “too easy”. Yet, he shockingly calls our public school system “one of America’s most successful institutions”. Public charter schools prove students can succeed academically despite having impoverished families and parents who lack advanced education. It is unconscionable that teachers’ unions insist on trapping inner-city children in under-performing schools. Rather than being successful, our public school system is our most systematically racist institution.
Submitted to the KC Star and WSJ (March 15, 2026)
Nuclear War is our biggest existential threat.
Iran’s current regime is determined to have nuclear weapons.
Therefore, this is a war for regime change to avoid Iran having nuclear weapons.
The current Iranian regime is also the biggest exporter of terrorism. And it has called for “Death to America” incessantly for nearly 50 years.
I have documentation of being a “never Trumper” since 1988. I have repeatedly lauded Separation of Powers as the key to our national success and have consistently, under both Republican and Democratic presidents, objected to Congress relinquishing power to the President.
Despite the previous paragraph, the world will be much safer if we topple the Iranian regime.
Many in the liberal press and many Democrats instigate opposition to the war by focusing attention on its disadvantages. Their efforts are damaging:
1. Because of the emphasis on the increasing price of oil, President Trump temporarily released sanctions on Russian oil, to the detriment of Ukraine.
2. If President Trump curtails activities prior to regime change, the world will be much less safe.
Slate Debate
We continue to be blessed with strong local candidates. However, candidates in many locales run for non-partisan positions such as school boards and community college trustees on slates with party backing and party identification.
That might help voters identify candidates' overall philosophies, and if you feel strongly about a particular issue, you might want to vote only for people who take that particular stance. But many issues are not clear-cut, and decisions benefit from robust, constructive discussion and careful consideration of alternatives.
Although I expect candidates to bring strong opinions, I fear that party affiliations and slates "label" candidates, setting them up to be more rigid in their positions, seeing themselves as having a duty to support their slate and a particular constituency, and viewing people who disagree as opponents rather than associates.
I believe the most valuable diversity is diversity in how people think. So, I generally prefer to have balance on a board rather than to elect a uniformly-minded slate. Election results suggest that voters are (blindly?) voting based on the slates. I suggest that voters take the time to select strong candidates from each slate.
Submitted October 18, 2025 to WSJ (slightly shorter version to KC Star)
I have documentation of being
a “never Trumper” since at least 1988, but I blame Democrats for the government
shutdown. Democrats could have refused
to fund the government because the Trump administration is acting
unconstitutionally, undermining separation of powers. Democrats could have demanded that Adelita
Grijalva be seated in the House (which Republicans are blocking to avoid release
of the Epstein files), that President Trump get Congressional approval for military
action in the Caribbean, etc. Instead, Democrats
shut down the government because they don’t like a law that was legally passed. That’s a terrible reason to shut down the
government. Worse, Democrats are objecting
to the APRA of 2021 which is a law drafted, promoted and passed by Democrats in
the Biden administration! Democrats don’t
like what they did, so they are shutting down the government. Democrats insult the public’s intelligence by
saying “Republicans control the government, so the shutdown is their fault”. Obviously, if the Republicans had complete
control, the government would not have been shut down. The shutdown is not only wrong, it is stupid
because it gives the administration opportunities to shut down projects most
precious to Democrats. Chuck Schumer
consistently strongly criticized such government shutdowns until the leftist
support for Mamdani in NYC increased his fear of losing the Democratic
nomination for his seat to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, prioritizing personal
ambition over the good for the country.
Why did we
cancel Disney? NOT because Jimmy Kimmel tried to convince viewers that
the man who killed Charlie Kirk was MAGA. That reprehensible act deserved
some consequences. Defending Kimmel as a comic doesn’t work because it
wasn’t part of a joke.
However,
Separation of Powers, the key reason for our country’s success, depends on
people performing their functions properly. Appropriate co-operation is
great, but cowardice is not. Neither is putting profits ahead of our
nation’s proper interests.
When
FCC Chairman Carr threatened Disney (“Frankly, when you see stuff like this, I
mean look, we can do this the easy way or the hard way,… These companies
can find ways to change conduct and take action, frankly, on Kimmel, or there’s
going to be additional work for the FCC ahead.”), Disney had a duty to
resist. Disney caved probably to maximize profits; we canceled to
demonstrate to Disney that kowtowing to power is not profitable.
I was
surprised to see WSJ print only letters on this topic that supported the WSJ
position. Even after waiting several days to see if the WSJ would provide
more balance, I found none. If I missed something, I apologize.
I
offer two opportunities for the WSJ to provide some balance:
- Please
see the letter that I sent below on June 12th. It makes
meaningful, unique points in favor of MAID. I would think you’d be
sensitive to the fact that your position actually causes some healthy
people to commit suicide.
- Even
better, I offer to partner with Compassion
& Choices, the preeminent advocate for MAID, to write an Op-ed for
the WSJ.
Would
you consider either of the above or do you have another solution to WSJ’s
present situation of having provided only one-sided information to its readers?
The WSJ makes
one good point in its “New York’s Assisted-Suicide Mistake”: NY’s bill lacks an
adequate waiting period. The USA has had MAID laws more than 30 years
without problems, yet the WSJ cites problems “around the world”. Does the
WSJ think the USA is not part of “the world”? The WSJ raises the specter
of “chronic conditions”, but we’ve had no such problems either. What
right does the government have to interfere if we want to avoid excruciating
pain for the last months of our lives and want to schedule our death so our
family/friends can be with us at the end? For many good reasons, MAID
deaths are not classified as suicide. My mother committed suicide at age
78 with probably 10 healthy years ahead of her SOLELY because her state did not
have a MAID law. She feared a health change and losing control of her
life to the government. Opponents to MAID want to force people to bear a
few miserable months but ignore the unintended consequence of some people
losing many healthy years.
Consider the following: First, he
imprisoned Venezuelans in El Salvador; you did nothing because you figured most
of those people were gang members. Then, he intimidated attorneys; you
did nothing because they weren't your attorneys. Then, he intimidated
judges; you did nothing because they weren't judging a case involving
you. He has also started intimidating the press, but you’re doing nothing
(not sure why). When he comes after you or your loved ones, who will be
left to protect you/them? You likely recognize that I'm re-phrasing
Martin Niemoller’s deservedly famous quote.
A good companion quote is from Rabbi
Hillel: “If not you, who? If not now, when?”
Submitted to WSJ on December 20, 2024
In 1999, I temporarily
boycotted my local newspaper and corresponded with its editor to protest
printing the names and pictures of the Columbine HS shooters on page 1. I feared such publicity would stimulate
copycats and maintained that showing their pictures was unnecessary and their
names could have been printed in an article continuation on a back page. The recent Wisconsin shooter wore a shirt
similar to the Columbine shooters’ shirts.
Might we have had fewer than 426 school shootings since Columbine if the
press publicized shooters less? Now the
media is continually publicizing the name and picture of the person who shot
the insurance executive. Might we see
more such murders because of this media behavior?
Published in the Kansas City Star, October 27, 2024
More choices
Both major parties oppose ranked choice voting, which would be banned in Missouri if Amendment 7 passes, because this simple system lets you vote for a candidate without risking being a spoiler. You simply rank your first choice, second choice and so on.
Assume Anne, Edward and Mary are running. You favor Mary, who has little chance. So, list Mary first, list Edward second and don’t list Anne (whom you want to lose).
If someone wins a majority of first-choice votes, she or he is elected. Anne wins in the first round if she gets more votes than Mary and Edward combined. Mary wasn’t a spoiler because if Mary’s votes had all gone to Edward, Anne would still have won.
If no one wins the first round, the last-place candidate’s votes are redistributed to their voters’ second choices. If Mary comes in third in the first round, your vote switches to Edward for the second round. It’s like the first round never existed. You got to vote for Mary and still pick Edward over Anne.
Ranking candidates is easy — no different from “I’d like chocolate chip ice cream, but if they don’t have that, I’ll take vanilla.”
Extremist candidates hate ranked choice because it can benefit the voter’s second choice.
Read more at: https://www.kansascity.com/opinion/letters-to-the-editor/article294409164.html#storylink=cpy
Submitted to WSJ on May 28, 2024
Peggy Noonan’s inspirational “Teach Your Kids To Love America” could have
been improved if she had acknowledged that it is important to teach students
about our failures so we can avoid them going forward and continue to
improve. Our founding documents are aspirational as well as
inspirational. The left says that people who disagree with CRT and the
1619 project want to whitewash history: not me or many others. She also
indicates that “kids from difficult circumstances” have “a violent or unhappy
family”; lots of such kids have wonderful families. She notes that “kids
from easier circumstances” can conclude that they “might as well be
corrupt”. That applies to all children. A big
problem of overly lax law enforcement is that it undermines parents trying to
teach their children moral behavior. Why should children develop
self-discipline when others run rampant without penalty?
Submitted to WSJ on April 4, 2024
Israel has
proven that it is strong and will defend itself. It achieved its goal in
killing two Iranian generals in its attack in Syria and Iran’s response did
minimal damage. Hence, Israel can afford to restrain itself here, rather
than risk a continued spiral to world war. Relay this message to your
friends in government and in Israel to help it reach Israeli decision-makers.
If you consider this relevant in deciding whether to publish this letter, both of my parents were holocaust survivors.
Printed by the Kansas City Star December 14, 2023
Hamas’ plan
I’ve criticized Israel’s response to Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack, but the fundamental Palestinian problem is that many Arab leaders reject peace, favoring destroying Israel. In 1948, 700,000 Arabs left Israel, whereas 15-20 million Muslims and Hindus left India and Pakistan a year earlier. Why don’t we have a corresponding Pakistani problem?
The answer: Muslim countries (except Jordan) have done little to welcome Palestinian refugees or help Palestinians develop economically. Egypt, Iraq, Iran and Lebanon have welcomed more than 4.5 times as many Syrian refugees in the past few years as Palestinians in 75 years.
Many Arab leaders rely on Palestinian suffering to bash Israel. For example, Hamas’ plan was that its butchery would stimulate Palestinian civilian deaths. Readers should consider Coleman Hughes’ “The Struggle for Black Freedom Has Nothing to Do with Israel” at colemanhughes.substack.com
Terrorists hijack commercial airplanes; deploy suicide bombers; offer bounties, martyrdom and special favors from Allah to murderers; and use human shields and hide fighters in schools, hospitals and mosques. Many Israelis care more about Palestinians than some Arab leaders.
I am sympathetic to Palestinians and think Islam is a great religion. Unfortunately, extremists hijacked Islam, and most Arab leaders have served their people poorly.
Read more at: https://www.kansascity.com/opinion/letters-to-the-editor/article282969423.html#storylink=cpy
Published by the Kansas City Star on September 22, 2023
A double problem
The Star’s Sept. 11 editorial about No Labels exposed inappropriate Republican actions but suggested Democrats support democracy. It also ripped the nonprofit No Labels as not truly centrist, suggesting that “preserving the republic” requires a vote against its candidates. Sadly, both of America’s dominant political parties oppose democracy.
- Democrats spent millions in 2022 to twist GOP primaries in 12 states to nominate Republicans who would be easier to beat.
- Democratic “election reform” bill H.R. 1 would enable vote harvesting for federal elections.
- Democrats recently went to court to block a third party’s ballot spot in Arizona.
Each party paints its opponents as immoral villains, seeking to divide us. Since 2010, No Labels has encouraged respectful exchanges between the parties. It encouraged the Problem Solvers Caucus (Democrats and Republicans in Congress who meet to find solutions).
Previously, about 25% of House members could block a vote on a bill supported by 75%. The Caucus upped that to 33%, which The Daily Beast lamented as “weakening the power of party leaders and committee chairs.”
In the 2018 midterm elections, No Labels supported 17 Democrats and 17 Republicans, all centrists. How can The Star justify calling that “faux-centrist” and quote a critic saying it wants “to punish the Democratic Party”?
Find more information about No Labels’ positions at nolabels.org
Read more at: https://www.kansascity.com/opinion/letters-to-the-editor/article279560149.html#storylink=cpy
Published by the Kansas City Star on April 8, 2022
Turn it around
Congratulations on your editorial endorsing ranked-choice voting. (March 30, 12A, “Ranked choice voting can break the extremist fever”) For many years, both political parties have worked hard to divide American citizens. Ranked-choice voting can help turn that tide. Thank you.
Read more at: https://www.kansascity.com/opinion/letters-to-the-editor/article260170745.html#storylink=cpy
Submitted maybe in 2018
Written to Max Londberg (jlondberg@kcstar.com) and Mary Kate Metivier (mmetivier@kcstar.com) of the Kansas City Star.
Before I provide specific concerns in this regard, including specific circumstances in which I feel the Kansas City Star has performed poorly, it would be helpful for you to know more about me so that you can judge my comments in context.
I have been a subscriber to the KC Star continuously since I moved to the Kansas City area in 1996 (exception: boycott, explained further later).
I am an Independent voter. For example, in this century I voted for President Bush and for President Obama the first time each of them were Presidential candidates but against each of them when they ran for re-election. I voted for Ian McMullen in 2016, having been a very early modified “Never Trump” person. (Modified because my position was “Never Trump” unless the alternative is Cruz.)
I am a fiscal conservative and a social liberal. However, as I have aged, my social viewpoints have become less liberal, less so because my opinions have changed as compared to changes in our population at large. For example, I have always been in favor of gay rights, which was a liberal position in my youth. But I have not favored redefinition of the word “marriage”, which caused my position during our recent debates to be more middle-of-the-road than liberal.
I perceive myself to be a political moderate. For example, I respect Hillary Clinton. I believe she sincerely wants to help people (especially children and women) and is a bright, hard-worker with energy. However, I don’t agree with her politics and see her as a divider rather than a unifier (albeit not to the unprecedented extent of President Trump). In my view, she is a sad example of “power corrupts”. Because she is so convinced that her motives are pure, she does not subject her actions to adequate ethical screens. (“How could I do anything unethical when I’m just trying to help people?”) I’m referring to this as a moderate position because so many people seem to either love Hillary or consider her to the devil incarnate.
I have been a professional actuary, which was a suitable career for me because I view issues based on long-term impact.
In my opinion, the greatest contributory factor to the success of the United States has been the separation of powers. As a youth, I supported strong central government, but less so as I have aged (i.e., I have shifted to what is typically considered to be governmental conservatism). I often quote Winston Churchill who said something to the effect that “If you are young and not a liberal, you don’t have a heart. If you are middle-aged and not a conservative, you don’t have a brain.”
Being a holocaust descendant may also influence my concern regarding potential long-term effects and for process. I cringe when people tell me “that could never happen here” because such sentiments increase our risk, in my opinion.
Our society believes “the ends justifies the means”, endorsing inappropriate action by their political party while excoriating the same actions by the other side. Such lack of integrity is very damaging to our country. Furthermore, in general, “the ends justifies the means” is a slippery slope.
As a former inner city school teacher, I have traditionally maintained that our under-performing education system is our country’s biggest problem. I now consider fake news to be our biggest risk.
In 1994, I saw the movie “Forrest Gump”. It was a wonderful story, but I am the only person I know who hated the movie. It sent chills up and down my body as I saw pictures of Forrest Gump with Marilyn Monroe and JFK. Such technology was new to me. It terrified me that people could be convinced of false information with doctored pictures and would develop distrust of accurate evidence on the belief that it might be false.
********************
Moving to your survey, the problem is not “typically not trusting media”. Most information in the media (and the KC Star in particular) is correct. The problem is the minority of material that is either inaccurate, misleading, biased, or irresponsible.
In the above-mentioned situation, the KC Star reporting was clearly inaccurate and misleading. I wondered how that “after 8 years” comment could get printed.
******************************
My following correspondence from 2016 discusses another occurrence which undermines trust in the KC Star. As noted above, I cherish process. Free speech is very important to me. The KC Star took a strong position against free speech and at the same time took steps to re-write history (a very scary action). By the way, I did not boycott at the time, but I blame myself for not having gone to the trouble of doing so at that time.
From: Claude Thau
To: Tony Berg (tberg@kcstar.com) <tberg@kcstar.com>; Derek Donovan (readerrep@kcstar.com) <readerrep@kcstar.com>; oped@kcstar.com
Subject: Article about rape
Dear Mr. Berg,
When I read Saturday’s “Midwest Voices” article about rape, I was uncomfortable with it, as explained below. However it can be valuable to read things that make you uncomfortable.
My wife and I did not discuss it until she showed me your commentary today (http://www.kansascity.com/opinion/editorials/article88705437.html), expressing her disagreement with your stance.
However, in my strong opinion, you did not give adequate reason for censorship and re-inventing history by purging Ms. Herrick’s article. Your justification is largely based on “If a person is incapacitated and someone takes advantage of them sexually, the law considers that rape or sexual assault and the victim is blameless”. Does that mean if I disagree with a law, I have no right to be heard?
My above comments would apply had Ms. Herrick suggested that the man was somewhat less responsible because of the woman being intoxicated. However, it is worth noting that her second and third paragraphs made it clear that her stance is that the man is not absolved at all!
In the middle of her fourth paragraph, she appears to segue from rape to situations of consensual sex that are regretted by the female later. That transition troubled me because it is not well-written. It would have been good for the Star to encourage her to clarify her writing. It is conceivable that the Star may have contributed to the confusion by failing to start a new paragraph when she wrote “And if you wake up…”, but I don’t know that she intended a new paragraph.
I strongly disagreed with what I inferred she was saying when she wrote “If a woman was too drunk to know what she was doing and should be excused for what happened, then why are men not allowed to be too drunk to make good decisions?” A state of created incapacity cannot absolve someone of a violent crime against another person.
I also disagreed with her suggestion that her son should run the other direction rather than help a drunk, unconscious woman. But recently a man was victimized in just such an occurrence. Her advice is improper in my opinion, but the issue is real and is important.
I understand that in McClenahan v. Cooley, the Tennessee Supreme Court concluded that “"Leaving a key in the ignition of an unattended automobile in an area where the public has access, be it public or private property, could be found by a reasonable jury to be negligent, whether or not a prohibitory statute is involved." This theory of negligence seems related to the position taken by Ms. Herrick. I don’t think that any such “negligence” reduces the responsibility of the person committing either crime. But I don’t think someone who would consider such action to be negligence should be censored.
I experienced two ironies related to your opinion today:
Why should I not cancel my subscription as a protest for your commentary today?
Respectfully,
Claude Thau
Phone direct: 913-403-5824
**********************
The KC Star is clearly left-leaning. Its left-leaning attitude comes across regularly, without generally being acknowledged by the Star. A striking example occurred in 2015 as documented by my correspondence below. Steve Kraske chose not to respond to my email of August 8th, 2015 nor to a second email from me 3 days later, after I received a response from Derek Donovan. (Kudos to Derek, by the way.)
Sent: Saturday, August 08, 2015 4:20 PM
To: Steve Kraske (skraske@kcstar.com) <skraske@kcstar.com>; Derek Donovan (ddonovan@kcstar.com) <ddonovan@kcstar.com>
Subject: A Striking Contrast between two recent articles of yours
Thanks for the articles you write in the KC Star and your KCUR and UMKC contributions, etc.
Today, you discussed a study by Patrick Miller and wrote that “Miller’s research… showed that 38 percent of partisans from both parties agreed that their parties should use any tactics necessary to win elections. Brace yourself: That includes voter suppression, stealing and even lying. It includes cheating and physical violence.” You wrote other appropriate (in my opinion) critical comments about such behavior.
In contrast, a couple of days ago you explained Democrat Claire McCaskill’s substantial investment of money and effort to help Todd Akin win the Republican nomination to run against her, because she felt that he was the only potential Republican candidate that she could defeat. I did not notice any criticism of her behavior. Generally, I think Claire McCaskill is a good person. But I think it is extremely unethical to interfere with the political process in the way she did. Good people can do bad things, especially if others lack the courage to challenge their behavior. The press, in particular, has such responsibility.
Why did you not express a value judgment regarding her behavior? People reading the two columns consecutively might well conclude that you are one of the dangerous partisans of whom you wrote today.
I hope you will explain what I’m missing here. If you criticized Claire McCaskill and I missed it, I apologize and will be very happy to be so informed.
Thank you.
Claude Thau
Phone direct: 913-403-5824
*********************
*********************
Nationwide, there has been a lot of poor reporting related to Trump. One example is the big hullabaloo about him accepting a call from Taiwan. Trump was assailed for violating protocol by accepting that call. Much more importantly, when President Obama then broke protocol by taking significant unnecessary foreign policy steps on the eve of Trump taking over apparently without discussion with Trump, I saw no media reports questioning President Obama for having failed to consult Trump. It is possible that there were some private backroom discussions, but I think you’d also believe that is very unlikely.
Regardless of whether you support abstaining from the UN vote on Israel and the sanctions on Russia, it is hard to imagine anyone really believing that a President should take such actions in the last few weeks of his tenure without discussion with the incoming President.
*********************
It has run into legal difficulties, probably due to the ambiguity as to its applicability to green card holders, etc.
Many people opined that it was unconstitutional and/or illegal to favor minority religions over the major religions of the 7 primarily-Muslim countries cited. However, NONE of the news reports I heard or read acknowledged that that wording in the executive order was immediately preceded by “to the extent permitted by law”. NPR posted a highlighted and annotated copy of the law on their web-site. Their highlighting in this area started with the first word after “to the extent permitted by law”. I don’t understand how a provision can be unconstitutional or illegal if it contains such wording. The implementation of the law may be illegal, but the provision can’t be illegal.
You can understand now why I wanted you to know that I was a “never Trump” person. I still am very disappointed that he is president and am scared of the impact he might have on the world. But the press has sometimes egged President Trump to be more extreme and has sadly made his anti-media statements into exaggerations rather than falsehoods.